2017 in Cardboard
Every board game I played
Here’s a list of all the board games I played for the first time in 2017, along with an extremely short first impression. This list doesn’t include games I had already played before, or the many many prototypes I played (mine and others). Also I probably missed a few!
Hey That’s My Fish!
It’s super cute and surprisingly thoughtful for how simple it is!
Has its moments but ultimately it’s one of those games that plays itself?
I had never heard of this or the original but it was surprisingly fun! Gotta try it as a drinking game.
Very entertaining! Ever so slightly multiplayer solitaire-ish and kind of long with 5p but I absolutely want to play again with fewer.
Folk game played with an app. Technically I’ve played this before but this is a specific variation on the rules that I hadn’t seen that worked really well.
Bang! The Dice Game
Some really clever stuff in here. Ultimately it’s still pretty fast and loose and the hidden roles are sort of weak, but it goes so quickly you can’t really complain.
Deception: Murder in Hong Kong
Breezy but incredibly engaging. All the best bits of Codenames and Dixit and Mysterium et al, the huge player count is a real nice luxury.
More fun than I thought it would be! Surprisingly crunchy.
Surprisingly strategic! Could be visually better and more accessible though?
Breezy! fun! It was legitimately exciting. And shorter than I thought. Although I’m not sure I groked how to get maximum control over what I was doing?
Some fantastic moments in this game. Atrocious graphics that were so disappointing because the game itself was great!
Sushi Go Party
Wow this is excellent. Makes an already great game so much better.
Pure negotiation game that is really excellent. It closes up as it goes on (your options become more constrained) which was unexpected and unique!
Tiny Epic Galaxies
A little too long with 5P? Lots of downtime. But the depth is there and the combos are real nice and the endgame is very fun!
A beautiful object! Plays very tactically but also seems to have a good amount of longevity.
Gets so much out of so little. I expected this game to be mainly an auction game but it’s really a push your luck game???
Some really clever if unthematic mechanisms in here. It’s pretty breezy but also has its tense moments.
Arkham Horror LCG
So intriguing and hard! I want to play more already. Maybe felt a bit too math-y?
Really really solid. It takes a full game to understand it though. Also what’s going on with the auctions? They feel backward in that I don’t have enough information to do them when we do them. Maybe they’re not meant to be a real mechanic.
Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective
Damn this game is engaging. Makes you feel terribly inept though. Also sometimes it’s hard to tell if the game itself is wrong or not.
It’s all luck but it does a really good job at keeping you engaged despite that.
SO CLEVER. One of the best co-op games I’ve ever played probably.
Watson and Homes
This is maybe better than Consulting Detective? Some of the mechanics feel like they get in the way of the problem solving a bit but it doesn’t feel like it drags on at all unlike CD. Also the heads down nature of it can be less engaging but the payoff is at the end.
So simple, so clever, so many satisfying moments. Some improvements to be made for sure but I can’t imagine a group of people who would dislike this game.
A bunch of really cool moments but few and far between in a game that is really really long.
A lot faster and cooler than I thought! And also a lot of room for variety. Really captures what a good Roguelike does.
Very multiplayer solitaire, this one. Still somewhat engaging but really I could have played a whole nother game in between turns.
Cute! We did pretty well! Not sure how to improve though, unlike Hanabi where maybe you develop new communication methods, this seems kind of set.
Win, Lose, Banana!
Tyrants of the Underdark
One of the better deckbuilding games, and I hate deckbuilding. The promotion mechanic needs to be in everything. Surprisingly balanced! Also long.
We were playing wrong! But it was still great. Very engine-y. It’s Catan but the game is the engine instead of the negotiation.
Still prone to AP! But stealing words is really fun. Maybe fewer ppl next time?
Legendary, this one. Can’t imagine it not being a new party staple a la Codenames.
Arkham Horror LCG, again (expansion)
Putting this back because the second time was great. After learning the decks a bit you really get into the theme and story. It’s not super fun when it’s hopeless though.
Actually more engaging than I thought it would be. It didn’t seem to get interestingly harder though, just harder.
Triple Agent (not a board game technically!)
Really good! Maybe a bit too chaotic but there’s some solid logical bluffing things going on. It happens a bit fast; maybe too fast to give people a good handle on how they should play? It feels really really hard for the VIRUS agents but the roles combat that somewhat.
Way less cooperative than i thought, because players’s needs are super individual. We thought it would be easier I guess so the monster won pretty fast. Perhaps that’s the rub of not playing collaboratively!
Way more fun than it has any right to be. Stupid scoring system and joker cards feel tacked on, but the concept is so simple and engaging!
Fox In The Forest
Great replacement for Love Letter, although it’s only 2 players. Dead simple but it’s hard to imagine ever solving it.
More fun than I thought it would be! Super light and easy to do something else while playing.
We played wrong the first time and it was way too long. It got way better the second time though! Still has some continuity problems but minor complaints there. Reminder to self to write a blog post about how noncolonialist this game feels.
Twin Tin Bots
Super satisfying and cute if not a little underbaked. I can’t tell if a 4 way tie in a 6 player game is good or not?
I was so afraid of this game but it turned out to be more digestible and way more fun than I thought! It has that point-grab at the end that I don’t like so much but it definitely feels super engaging to play through.
Professor Evil and the Citadel of Time
It’s a chunky puzzle! Pretty satisfying although it has that coop dice rolling unfortunate crap.
OMG so amazing. Such a realistic economic simulation and one of the best betting slash auction games. Also the fact that you get money when you lose an auction is another example of a band-aid rule that isn’t actually a band-aid rule and is super important!
God what a clusterfuck. There’s something cool in here but the design is so bad and inaccessible! It’s probably also overly complex, but maybe that’s the point?
Dead of Winter
Finally! This was pretty cool. The crossroads cards are neat. We didn’t have a traitor but it’s still hard to win? Somewhat unsatisfying but I’ll know for next time.
Never not funny. I playtested this a bunch and it’s so cool to see the final product!
Wasteland Express Delivery Service
We played completely wrong but I also wonder if it’d go smoother with fewer people. It’s a bit slow but still very exciting.
So chaotic and fun. 5p is completely different than 8p. One is a deduction game, the other is just (welcome) sillyness.
Some cool co-op stuff going on! Overall v solid but didn’t feel the ‘Resistance’ aspect too hard.
Welcome Back To The Dungeon
pretty neat push your luck game, it took a while to figure out what the strategy was.
Caverna: Cave vs Cave
Perfect example of a game that is so solid but also bone-dry. A bit tired of those.
Neat little puzzle here that could be adapted into a mobile game? It’s sort of just trivia.
So quick and fast and meaty! I felt simultaneously like I experienced everything it had to offer but also that I needed to play more to understand the strategy? We both did really badly.
Finally! Really solid strategy stuff. So tight and clean.
I appreciate the different games going on here but essentially they’re all the same game and it gets old fast.
A little plodding, the mechanics are solid but I’m not sure there were any good “moments” in this game.
Food Chain Magnate
Finally! So heavy and we didn’t finish it but it feels like it would be worth playing through: probably everyone needs to be briefed beforehand and that would help.
Clank! in Space
Definitely improves on the original Clank! Still a bit long but dang those final few turns are exhilarating.
I can see why this is a classic. I had no idea there was a “campaign” but it really helped introduce the mechanics and stuff. Definitely want to play more.
INSTANT CLASSIC this one. Crowd pleaser and crowd drawer. Also beautiful table presence.
So simple and good! We played with one too many people but I’d love to play proper.
Draws a crowd. Really really entertaining. Would be great drunk! But probably once is enough.
Feels like a chunky interesting problem that you’d only get more savvy at over time, but not many super great “moments” in here either.
Fury of Dracula
We won unexpectedly!! It’s hard and brutal and you have to get lucky but it’s so thematic and excellent.
Legends of Andor
P solid co-op. I like the campaign and how it telegraphs that you need to team up.
This game needs to tell you not to spend all your money. Besides that I’m interested in playing again!
Pandemic Legacy Season 2
It’s reverse pandemic! But also it’s a completely different game!
Felt a bit too easy because we didn’t go mad. Was it luck? I can see how it could get silly but it needs more enforcing.
We messed up the rules a bit and it took a long time but it’s very interesting! Very swingy in terms of how easy it is to lose your lead when other players realize you’re ahead. But I guess that’s the point?
Cute little card drafting game that has a bunch more to it than meets the eye. Or maybe it doesn’t?
Super super solid and simple. It seems like you can definitely get good at it if you played a lot.
Hab & Gut
Such an amazing stock game. It’s really platonically perfect and I need to mine it for ideas.
This game is based off the folk game Ghost and not the folk game Traitor and it needs to be Traitor really badly. It’s so close! It’s v well executed though.
It’s Memory but with just enough mechanics to make it engaging! Good drinking game.
It was everything I wanted it to be. Love the ramp up in difficulty and really want to play more!
Whoah this game is brilliant. Didn’t take too long, had surprising dynamics even with so few mechanics!
So hard!! I love the art and the fact that the people are real (and related to the game designers!)
I’ve never played Terra Mystica but I liked this a lot. It’s sandboxy and lots of stuff depends on the variable setup and the race abilities and it’ll probably take a few plays to get used to the resource management but I’m excited to play again!